A girls’s faculty goes coed, enraging college students and alumnae

100 and twenty-five years after its founding as the primary Catholic college within the U.S. to grant four-year levels to girls, Notre Dame of Maryland College goes coed—a lot to the chagrin of many college students and alumnae.

The one remaining girls’s faculty in Maryland announced last Tuesday that it’ll start enrolling undergraduate males in fall 2023. The choice was made on the advice of an enrollment process drive assembled final yr by the college’s Board of Trustees, which examined falling enrollment rates at women’s colleges throughout the nation. NDMU’s personal undergraduate enrollment has fallen significantly lately, from 1,169 in fall 2014 to 807 in fall 2021.

“The Board acknowledged that to ensure that NDMU to flourish for years to return, we wanted to broaden our mission,” Board of Trustees chair Patricia McLaughlin wrote in a press release.

Many present college students and alumnae argue that by changing into a coeducational establishment, the college shouldn’t be increasing its mission however abandoning it. Each who spoke to Inside Larger Ed mentioned that the shift would basically alter the NDMU expertise and that they have been blindsided by the choice, which was made behind closed doorways.

“The choice was made solely by the Board of Trustees, with no enter from college students, workers, college, or alumni,” mentioned Alex Malinowski, a present senior at NDMU. “It’s actually heartbreaking. We really feel extremely disrespected.”

Subsequent fall gained’t be the primary time the Baltimore faculty has admitted males: NDMU’s weekend faculty for grownup undergraduates, launched in 1975, has at all times been coeducational. However Christine Baumgarten, an alumna who additionally labored within the college’s workplace of enrollment till 2015, mentioned there’s a distinction between having males on campus and eschewing the id of a girls’s undergraduate faculty.

“Ladies’s schools are wholly distinctive experiences,” she mentioned. “On the undergraduate stage, notably when you may have college students popping out of highschool doing their core identity-forming, it’s so empowering for girls to have an area in a classroom the place they don’t really feel judged, the place they’ll really feel heard and be engaged as girls rising into professionals.”

A spokesperson for NDMU didn’t reply to Inside Larger Ed’s questions on backlash to the choice, as a substitute pointing to a proper assertion and an FAQ page, each launched Tuesday after the announcement.

The Baltimore college’s swap to coeducation makes it the newest in a long line of ladies’s schools which have both opened as much as males or shuttered their doorways.

Emerald Archer, the chief director of the Ladies’s School Coalition, of which NDMU is a member, mentioned many ladies’s schools are dealing with a “good storm” of enrollment and monetary woes which have pressured them right into a nook.

“Ladies’s schools are having to make some actually arduous selections … however I’m assured that management for our faculties are exhausting each possibility earlier than closing or going coed,” she mentioned. “These selections should not made frivolously.”

A ‘Mission-Altering Choice’

College students at NDMU bought the information that their faculty was going coed the identical approach because the broader public: by a press launch that arrived of their e-mail inboxes with out warning Tuesday afternoon.

Malinowski, who was within the eating corridor when the e-mail got here by, mentioned that when college students realized what it meant, “chaos ensued.”

“Individuals have been shouting, upset, crying,” she mentioned. “It was simply actually an astounding second for the college to shred its historical past so rapidly and with out warning.”

Alumnae and school have been equally thrown by the announcement. Nancy Tarr Hart, an alumna of NDMU’s grownup faculty, mentioned she “discovered her voice” at NDMU, and he or she credit her expertise at a girls’s faculty with serving to her jump-start a second act in her life. Years after graduating, she was requested to return and educate philosophy, later changing into the division chair—a place she held till her retirement in Could. She mentioned she was “shocked and angered” by NDMU’s determination.

“It felt like I used to be punched within the intestine,” she mentioned. “Actually, I felt betrayed.”

College students and alumnae say the dearth of transparency across the board’s determination made the information all of the extra upsetting, and the college dealt with the rollout poorly, with out acknowledging the magnitude of the transition.

“It’s a large, sweeping change, a mission-altering determination, and but not a single particular person exterior of the board and directors knew this was even being thought of earlier than the press launch,” mentioned Baumgarten. “It’s changing into a case research in how to not do institutional change.”

Dozens of alumnae voiced their opposition to the transfer in a gathering with NDMU president Marylou Yam held over Zoom Thursday night time. On alumnae Fb teams and different social media websites,  many expressed anger blended with nostalgic remembrances of what they described because the distinct, community-centered expertise of attending a girls’s faculty.

College students are organizing to specific their disapproval. At an on-campus data session Thursday, greater than 50 present college students walked in with tape over their mouths. Malinowski, who helped set up the protest, mentioned the transfer was symbolic of the college “shutting out” college students from the decision-making course of.

“It’s simply actually unfair that the Board of Trustees made this determination earlier than asking for anybody’s recommendation or how we felt about it,” mentioned Narelle Hernandez, one other NDMU senior.

On Friday, dozens of scholars gathered exterior Yam’s workplace all through the day for a silent sit-in. Malinowski mentioned it might be overly optimistic to assume pupil motion may reverse the college’s determination, however that it was essential to her and her friends to vocalize their discontent.

“Our purpose is for the president and Board of Trustees to know they missed Notre Dame girls, a robust drive on campus which can be sad with the choice,” she mentioned. “We’ll proceed to struggle for the school to stay a girls’s faculty, however proper now our major purpose is to ensure everybody’s voice is heard.”

Tarr Hart mentioned she thought there have been quite a lot of different choices to spice up enrollment that didn’t contain “abandoning the mission” of NDMU. The fallout from going coed, she believes, will solely make the college’s struggles extra acute.

“I truthfully assume they’re going to lose present college students, potential college students and donors,” she mentioned, including that she was unlikely to make any extra donations to her alma mater.

Malinowski concurred. She mentioned that if she weren’t graduating subsequent fall, she would contemplate transferring, and that a lot of her youthful friends have been mulling over whether or not to remain.

Hernandez mentioned she selected NDMU due to its historic mission as a girls’s faculty. Whereas she’s going to graduate earlier than any males are enrolled, she worries that underclasswomen and potential college students might be “robbed of the expertise” that she credit with serving to her discover her voice and are available into her personal.

“Because it’s an all-women’s faculty, girls who’re introverts achieve the energy to have the ability to communicate up extra in school in order that they’ll get out of their shell,” Hernandez mentioned. “As soon as they introduce males into courses, that’s going to be more durable.”

Eric Bryan, vp of enrollment methods for the Parish Group, has labored with many small schools, together with girls’s schools. He mentioned that in his expertise, girls’s schools don’t flip to a coed transition until all different enrollment-boosting choices have been exhausted. Bryan additionally questioned the knowledge of counting on males to spice up enrollment, as males accounted for 71 % of the general faculty enrollment decline over the previous 5 years, based on data from the Nationwide Pupil Clearinghouse; as of spring 2021 virtually 60 % of all faculty college students have been girls, a file excessive.

“In plenty of these instances, it truly is a last-ditch effort the place they don’t see one other path ahead,” he mentioned. “In any other case, why would you danger alienating 100-plus years of alumnae?”

However Baumgarten, Tarr Hart and others mentioned NDMU’s secretive decision-making course of and shock announcement didn’t give the college neighborhood an opportunity to plan different options or fundraise their approach out of the issue, like supporters of Sweet Briar College did when the Virginia girls’s faculty appeared getting ready to closure in 2014.

Baumgarten added that whereas the information got here as a shock, she knew there was at all times an opportunity that NDMU would go the way in which of different struggling girls’s schools, together with the College of New Rochelle in New York and the University of St. Joseph in Connecticut. She’s been a member of the Fb group NDMU Alumnae In opposition to Co-education within the Ladies’s School since 2018.

“Each girls’s faculty is aware of someplace behind their head that they’re one administration away from a choice like this,” she mentioned. “It’s important to be continuously vigilant.”

Ladies’s Schools ‘Working Out of Runway’

A little bit over 50 years in the past, there have been 230 girls’s schools within the U.S., based on a 2014 report from the Ladies’s School Coalition. After NDMU transitions to undergraduate coeducation, there might be simply 33, a lower of 86 %.

Some, like Converse College in South Carolina, have gone the route of NDMU and transitioned to coeducation. Others, like Judson College in Alabama, merely closed up store.

Bryan mentioned that when the going will get tough, girls’s schools ought to look to tell apart themselves by their distinctive identities relatively than abandon them. It may be tougher—and doubtlessly costlier— than merely “letting within the different half of the inhabitants,” Bryan mentioned, nevertheless it’s doubtless price it in the long term. He famous that that appears to be very true for NDMU, which is surrounded by different coed Catholic universities in Baltimore—together with Loyola College Maryland, with which NDMU shares a library.

“One of many first issues I inform schools combating enrollment is, ‘You want a solution to outline the distinction of your establishment,’” he mentioned. “When you’ve already bought one inbuilt, why would you abandon that?”

The enrollment woes girls’s schools face should not evenly distributed. Fewer than 2 % of feminine undergraduates within the U.S. enroll in non-public, nonprofit girls’s schools and universities yearly, based on WCC knowledge; of these, greater than half attend simply 9 schools.

Archer of the WCC fears that the extra elite girls’s schools—such because the Seven Sisters, a gaggle of the nation’s oldest all-women establishments, together with Smith and Wellesley Schools—could also be all that’s left of the sector if present tendencies proceed. She mentioned that if smaller girls’s schools like NDMU are misplaced or go coed, a subset of the inhabitants that these girls’s schools serve—specifically, younger girls from deprived backgrounds—would be the ones who miss out on a high quality training. Based on a WCC report from 2014, 94 % of ladies’s faculty college students obtain monetary help, and 48 % are Pell Grant recipients.

“NDMU is a bat sign to indicate that ladies’s schools want federal help, they usually want it now,” Archer mentioned. “We’ve sounded the alarm, however there may be this trickle of press releases the place schools are having to make arduous selections, and we’re working out of runway.”

Baumgarten mentioned the speed at which girls’s schools are disappearing makes it arduous to think about future generations having fun with the identical vary of institutional selection that she had when making use of within the late 2000s.

“I’ve joked with my husband that if we ever have a daughter, I might take her to each single girl’s faculty, as a result of I might actually need her to see the distinction in what that sort of surroundings does,” she mentioned. “At this level, it’s going to be a really quick highway journey.”

Our names are Fareedah and Kamilah Amoo. We are seven and five year’s old sisters and live in Ontario, Canada, with our parents and little brother, Awad. We love writing stories, painting on canva, coding, reading books, and enjoying arts and crafts. Our goal is to motivate every child worldwide to read more books.

Related Posts



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Stay Connected


Recent Stories